Friday, 14 November 2014

Sites of History, Sites of Learning: Reflections on the 2014 Canada and the War Experience Teachers' Tour

At the heart of every educator’s teaching philosophy is the desire to empower students, whatever the subject and discipline.  For teacher-historians, historical content provides the building blocks that allow students to (among other things) understand the past as a path to the present, develop their cultural literacy, participate and engage in the national community (citizenship) and cultivate broadly transferable skills.  Perhaps most importantly, educators instill in their students the value, capacity and willingness of asking why. But, how do we get our students to do so? 


The 2014 Canada and the War Experience: Teachers' Tour to France and Belgium provided a range of experiences and methods for teachers to do just this: get students to ask "why" questions about history to initiate higher order skills of critical thinking, inquiry and analysis.  I found three methods (areas?) to be particularly engaging and applicable.
Part I: Soldier’s Tales
Grave of Pte. Russell Lee O'Connor at
Dieppe Canadian War Cemetery in
St-Aubin-sur-Scie, France
Sources are the foundation of history, a truth strongly (and importantly) reinforced by the War Experience Tour.  Engaging both primary and secondary sources while preparing for the tour and throughout the program, challenged me to ‘think like a student’ while developing and practicing strategies and activities transferrable to my own classroom.  By including primary documents, Tour participants put on their ' historians cap' to consider a source’s historical context.  For me, the reaching, writing and presentation of a Soldier’s biography powerfully brought home this point.  My biography traced the service of Pte. Russell O’Connor (The Essex Scottish).  Importantly, reading his service record and constructing his personal narrative transcended the ‘history skill-set’ and allowed me to consider and question my own ideas about the past, conflict and indeed meaning of citizenship.  Empathetic engagement with a single (lost) life not only introduced me to the Second World War on a more intimate and personal level but also reminded me of the ways in which the past can instruct us beyond simply what happened and why.  Simply, this one exercise spoke to the very essence of why history in the classroom matters.
Part II: (No Man’s) Land 
The Fields of Passchendaele,
Passchendaele, France
In the contemporary curriculum and classroom, much emphasis rests on varied perspectives.  Indeed, we’ve come a long way in recognizing that helping students grasp concepts requires a myriad of approaches.  The Tour’s focus on ‘walking the ground’ of past battles reinforced the importance of differentiation and varying perspectives.  First, considering battlefield geography through maps and charts accesses higher order thinking skills to show patterns and empower problem solving. Second, walking the ground itself geography provided insights and context to more fully understanding, interpreting and appreciating both textual primary sources and secondary sources. For me, this opportunity was powerfully demonstrated at Passchendaele.  In short, to more fully grasp why Allied forces proceeded as they did, one needed to literally see the terrain and consider the impact of water tables and drainage on the battle-space itself.  The Study Tour takes teachers to the space where the battles themselves were fought.  As teacher-historians, being there, seeing the ground and engaging with it provides indispensible tools for helping students to both coherently recollect the past, and to more richly consider and appreciate it. But perhaps even more importantly for me, walking the ground, feeling its dips and contours created deep connections to the space and ultimately to the memory and meaning of the events that took place there.     
Part III: Myth, Memory and Meaning
Anna at the Essex Scottish Regiment's
Red Beach Memorial
Beaches of Dieppe, France
At the heart of the Tour was a profound question for participants:  What did the wars mean?  At one level, lectures, seminars and presentations focused on meaning in the context of the events themselves.  For example, what did the Battle of Dieppe mean in August 1942?  On another, perhaps less accessible level, moments walking through cemeteries and visiting monuments asked us to consider not just meaning but memory and myth.  The meaning of such sites of memory change over time, construct and challenge collective memory and myths. While, akin to walking the ground, I cannot bring students to these sites, my own experiences there (and a great number of photographs) provides yet another perspective on war and its impact to take into the classroom. 
The Essex Scottish Regiment's
Red Beach Memorial,
Windsor, Ontario
For example, having students research Canadian monuments says much about the war but even more about realities and post-war needs.  Surely, such considerations move student engagement far beyond history as simply ‘facts and dates’ to consider identity, belonging, citizenship and the development of the imagined community.  For me, the need to consider memorialization and meaning was profoundly reinforced at Red Beach in Dieppe.  Far beyond the objectives detailed by operation plans or the subsequent historical debates, is the raid’s memory and meaning imbedded at the heart of a community.  Shortly before travelling to France, I had been to Windsor Ontario at Dieppe Gardens, the city’s historical site of memory, a proxy space on the banks of Detroit River rather than the Atlantic.  Yet, the two spaces where profoundly linked by identical memorials, ensuring that even if the land itself was different, the meaning of the sacrifice was not. 
The 2014 Canada and the War Experience: Teachers' Tour proved an enriching and challenging experience.  This opportunity to engage directly with the landscape as well as historians and teachers across Canada has had a significant impact on my teaching ‘toolbox’ and has empowered me with fresh critical and analytical approaches to teaching. 
For more information about the tour and how to apply see: http://www.unb.ca/fredericton/arts/centres/gregg/tours/cleghorn/index.html

No comments:

Post a Comment